Welcome to the eighth ‘The best of rbutr’ email. Big apology for the huge delay between #7 and #8, the reason is provided at the bottom of this email with a picture. That said, the wait was worth it, because this week’s email is a great one…
Click here to subscribe and receive ‘The best of rbutr’ via email.

rbutr organises the internet into productive, meaningful discussions.
Source Articles Response Articles
ya canna change the laws of physics image
Awesome! Kickstarter for AA sized lithium ion capacitor battery which recharges in 30 seconds! Or is it…?
30 Second Charging, Rechargeable Battery – kickstarter.com Graphene / Lithium Ion Capacitor Kickstarter BS – eevblog.com
Someone has created a capacitor based battery which recharges in 30 seconds but lasts as long as a normal AA battery and they need some funding to manufacture them for retail sale. The capacitor will be graphene, not lithium ion, the creator hasn’t shown actual test results for the battery, the best known graphene capacitor can’t do what he claims his does, and most importantly, the maths simply doesn’t work out.
giant spaceship unrelated to EmDrive and nasa
NASA and the creation of propellantless engines. Are they possible or not?
Nasa validates ‘impossible’ space drive – wired.co.uk Don’t Get Too Excited About NASA’s New Miracle Engine – io9.com
A team from NASA presented evidence that “impossible” microwave thrusters seem to work. This actually repeats the results obtained by a Chinese team last year. Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence, and there isn’t enough evidence yet that this extraordinary claim actually works.
Gaza–Israel conflict
gaze under attack
Are Israel’s recent actions defensible? A look at why some don’t want to criticise Israel’s actions, and why others think they are inexcusable.
Why Don’t I Criticize Israel? – samharris.org Sam Harris defends his silence on Gaza slaughter (or tries to anyway) – mondoweiss.net
Harris doesn’t think Israel should exist as a Jewish state, but also thinks that Israel has handled the conflict with extreme restraint and tolerance for the genocidal desires expressed by Hamas. Harris’ arguments are severely one sided, focussing on the negative aspects of Hamas as if that is all that exists of the Palestinians, and ignoring the negative aspects of Israel, such as the Gaza blockade and land grabs on the west bank.
Hamas tunnels into Israel terrorism
Media presentation of the Israel-Gaza conflict vs the numbers. What does Terrorism really mean?
Tunnels Lead Right to the Heart of Israeli Fear – nytimes.com Terrorism in the Israeli Attack on Gaza – firstlook.org
Hamas has been building tunnels into Israel for years now, and Israelis fear that they will be used for terrorist attacks and kidnappings. If terrorism is to mean the killing of civilians as a means of furthering political or military goals, then who are the real terrorists in this situation? Hamas, having killed 3 Israeli civilians, or Israel, having killed 826 Palestinian civilians?
Lifespan Extension
Elderly People sign for ageing debate longevity research
Who will benefit from increasing our healthy lifespans?
This is thrilling life-extension news – for dictators and the ultra-rich – theguardian.com Ageing revolution must benefit us all – theguardian.com
As science approaches the possibility of extending our lifespans, it isn’t as easy to dismiss the concerns it raises as some would like to think. Ageing is a global problem and interventions that extend healthy lifespan would be cheaper than treating age related diseases. As for dictators – most die from violence, not old age.
Atheism billboard
Issues of race and diversity within the atheism movement
Atheism has a big race problem that no one’s talking about – washingtonpost.com Atheism, Race, and Social Justice – atheistrev.com
The atheist movement needs to do more than trot out black speakers to talk about equality – it needs to start actively working on issues of inequality between the races and sexes. As important as those issues are, they are not the mission of secular and atheist groups. People are free to join multiple movements and can participate in social activism for racial and sexual equality AND a secular society without needing to get everything in one organisation.
obama speaking
Why are Obama and the Democrats talking less about income inequality after previously identifying it as a top concern?
With Democrats split on inequality issues, Obama shifts talk away from income gap – washingtonpost.com Obama, Inequality and Wall Street Donors – fair.org
Despite identifying inequality as a top concern while campaigning, Obama has shifted discussion away from talk of inequality as minimum wage and gender pay gap are thought to resonate with a broader group of voters. The Post frames the issue as a debate between left-leaning populists and “moderate” Democrats trying to avoid “class warfare.” But the piece offers no real evidence that people are less concerned with inequality or measures that might fight it.
You may have noticed the long delay in releasing this email. This is why… Leonardo Greenup was born on the 21st of July, 2014
Leonardo Greenup

Thank you once again to the users who submitted the rebuttals which have made up this ‘The best of rbutr’ post: EEVblog, mleonard, scottmcgreal, and BTR.

On account of the recent birth of my son, there isn’t much that has been happening with rbutr over the last few weeks, but stick with us, there will be a lot more happening over the next few months.

Subscribe to receive this post as an email!

Follow us on Twitter. Like us on Facebook. Follow us on G+.

Share Button


Welcome to our seventh Best of rbutr email. This week we have George Clooney, feminism, computer games, Antarctica, Amazon, e-readers, organic food, terrorism, potato salad and orange is the new black! Click here to subscribe to receive The best of rbutr via email.

rbutr logoThe internet and the world wide web made instant access to all information possible.
Google made it easy to find what you were looking for.
rbutr makes what you find meaningful.
Source Articles Response Articles
What did George Clooney’s mother in law say to the Daily Mail?
EXCLUSIVE – ‘She can do better’: Amal Alamuddin’s mother ‘is unimpressed with George Clooney and wants daughter to marry within their strict Lebanese religious sect’ – dailymail.co.uk Exclusive: Clooney responds to ‘Daily Mail’ report – usatoday.com
Baria Alamuddin, George Clooney’s mother in law is part of the Druze sect of Islam, and wanted her daughter to marry within that religion, as is tradition. She also thinks her daughter could have done better. The Daily Mail have made this story up, and it is very dangerous for them to have done so, as it invokes the death of the bride for marrying out of that religious sect.
The value of organic foods vs social perception
The tyranny of the organic mommy mafia – nypost.com The Assault on Organics – fair.org
Some parents are becoming aggressive organic food evangelizers, even though there is no indication that organic food is better for us in any way. Just because normal food hasn’t been found to harm us, doesn’t mean it is as good as organic. Many published papers have found a range of benefits of eating organic.
rbutr Salad
Got $10 for Potato Salad? Nah, have $59,000 instead. Seriously.

So this one is here just for a little bit of fun and to show rbutr isn’t only for serious discussions. I’m sure most of you have heard about the Potato Salad Kickstarter which has raised $59,000 already (24 days to go still!). Anyway, after 2 years of funding rbutr out of our own pockets, we’ve reached the point where we are going to need additional funding to help us get to the next stage. In a couple of months time we will be running our own crowdfunding campaign, and if we can’t beat a potato salad, I think I will cry…

So stay subscribed to find out when we launch that, and follow us on the usual social media channels: Twitter, Facebook, and Google Plus.

Antarctica is gaining a lot of sea ice – but only in area covered, not in total amount.
AntarcticaClimate ChangeSea Ice
Global warming computer models confounded as Antarctic sea ice hits new record high with 2.1million square miles more than is usual for time of year – dailymail.co.uk David Rose and the Antarctic sea ice misrepresentation? – wordpress.com
The levels of Antarctic sea-ice last week hit an all-time high – confounding climate change computer models which say it should be in decline. What David Rose is referring to is the increase is sea ice area, not volume. The Arctic is losing sea ice volume at 10 times the rate that the Antarctic is gaining it.
Video Games
Sony vs Microsoft: Who cares the most about their customers?
And This is Why Sony Cares More About Gamers Than Microsoft – gameskinny.com Rebuttal: Does Sony care more about gamers than Microsoft? – gamezone.com
Sony cares much more about their customers because they take a loss on most of their games, just so they can continue to support fresh promising talent. The article does very little to support its claim that Sony takes better care of its customers than Microsoft, relying entirely on the one point that they take a loss on most of their games. Microsoft do a lot more than just that though.
Are women just objects for use in computer games, or do computer games portray everyone as objects?
Women as Background Decoration: Part 1 – Tropes vs Women – youtube.com ‘Feminism’ Vs FACTS (Anita Sarkeesian DESTROYED!) – youtube.com
Computer games have been using women as decorative backgrounds for decades. This video explores the sexualised object trope used in computer games. Any person can be a subject or an object depending on how you view them, and in computer games far more men are objectified than women.
Amazon vs Hachette continues. Now we hear from some best selling authors too!
Child, Grisham, Patterson in Amazon protest – thebookseller.com One-Percent Authors Want To End Destructive Conflict, Bring Order to the Galaxy – techdirt.com
A number of bestselling authors have written an open letter to Amazon criticizing the way they have treated the publishing agency Hachette, and the authors published by Hachette. Amazon has sold more books than any, made publishing more accessible than anyone else, established the e-book market, and is the company authors should be siding with in this dispute, not the corporate giant publishing company Hachette.
Are e-readers already being replaced by other devices?
The E-Reader Death Watch Begins – slate.com Death of the e-reader? – tysonadams.com
More people carry smart phones and tablets with them all the time now, so e-readers are becoming less popular, and the sales of them are declining. Sales of e-readers will decline not because they are less popular, but because the market has matured. People only buy one e-reader, so you can’t keep selling them to the same people.
Terrorists are always looking for new ways to bomb us – or old ways. Whatever works really.
Terrorists Team Up in Syria to Build Next Generation of Bombs – abcnews.go.com Toothpaste Terrorism? Been There, Done That – fair.org
Just outside of Syria, al Qaeda linked terrorists are working to develop a new generation of bombs which can be smuggled aboard commercial planes. Far from being a “new generation,” the toothpaste tube bomb has been around for almost four decades.
Orange is the New Black Doesn’t Like Men
Thank you to our fantastic active members! rbutr is nothing without you.
Thank you once again to the users who submitted the rebuttals which have made up this ‘best of rbutr’ post: BTR, tscanlon, Matt Sully, and Eylrid.
Subscribe to receive this post as an email!

Follow us on Twitter. Like us on Facebook. Follow us on G+.

Share Button


SydStart Pitch Slides

July 1, 2014

I didn’t get to film my actual pitch on the SydStart second qualifying day, so decided to do a quick version of it on my computer. I think my live version was a bit smoother and came across better, since I had an actual audience to talk to (talking to a computer feels weird). But […]

Share Button
Read the full article →

Student debt, editing Wikipedia, and healthcare rankings. The best of rbutr #6

June 30, 2014

Welcome to the slightly-delayed best of rbutr email #6! Click here to subscribe to receive The best of rbutr via email. rbutr makes the internet correct itself. Source Articles Response Articles Technology If Wikipedia editors use private forums to discuss their editing, is that a bad thing? WikipediaSkepticismTechnology Guerrilla Skepticism on Wikipedia project – A […]

Share Button
Read the full article →

Sex, revolution and warp drive technology. It’s been a crazy week at rbutr. The best of rbutr #5

June 19, 2014

Welcome to our fifth instalment of The Best of rbutr. Click here to subscribe to receive The best of rbutr via email. It is always better to be unsure, than to be sure but wrong.Why rbutr must share misinformation Source Articles Response Articles Politics What did the Las Vegas shooters believe in? Whose revolution were […]

Share Button
Read the full article →

Why rbutr must share misinformation…

June 18, 2014

Yes, you read that heading right. We admit to sharing misinformation over rbutr. We admit that things which we know are not true, are being shared with people who may have never encountered the erroneous claims and arguments. We admit it, and we stand by the claim that it is absolutely necessary. Necessary for what? Necessary […]

Share Button
Read the full article →

Nanoparticles in your food, the Turing test, a Sydney shark attack and more – The best of rbutr #4

June 13, 2014

Welcome to our 4th issue of the best of rbutr. Click here to subscribe to receive The best of rbutr via email. rbutr maps inter-website discussions and makes it super easy for you to follow them. Remember: Anyone can submit claim-rebuttal connections, and rbutr doesn’t discriminate or take any position on the issues being discussed. […]

Share Button
Read the full article →

This week in rbutr… 9 June 2014

June 9, 2014

Subscribe to receive this post via email. Note: The articles on the right (below) critique the articles on the left, but that does NOT mean the articles on the left are necessarily incorrect, or that the articles on the right are necessarily correct. rbutr just shows the discussion; we don’t tell you what to think. […]

Share Button
Read the full article →

The best of rbutr… 2 June 2014

June 2, 2014

Welcome to our second issue of “The best of rbutr”. See the first issue in our blog here, with a bit of an explanation of what it is all about and the inspiration behind this idea. Subscribe to receive The best of rbutr via email. “One of the basic premises which lies behind the rbutr […]

Share Button
Read the full article →

The Right to Know…

May 27, 2014

One of the basic premises which lies behind the rbutr project is the belief that if you are accessing information, then you have the right to know if someone has critiqued that information. If someone else has taken the time to respond, criticise or argue against the content you are accessing, then that response is potentially […]

Share Button
Read the full article →